
17
2012What Turns on Gender?
Yeah, I’m a guy. And a gal. Why can’t I be both at once?
I have tried for quite some time now to try to conceptualize my gender identity. I have rejected many paradigms, but have yet to settle on one that feels right.
In some sense, I am both male and female. But, that makes me two people, and I’m not really, am I?
To the extent that I feel that doing things as a woman that I don’t allow myself to do or feel or be as a man – things like feeling sensual or emotional, being attracted to men, dancing alone at a club – the obvious fact is the I am doing them as me, whatever that is.
Perhaps I am neither. But that just doesn’t feel right. It is hard to fathom having neither gender when it seems so much further removed from my reality than being both genders.
Perhaps then, I am beyond gender? It takes a bit of hubris to believe that gender rules simply don’t apply to me, especially when I wouldn’t go so far as to suggest that society should abandon the concept of gender.
But, perhaps I should…
What purpose is served by splitting people up into male and female?
The thing of it is that it is relatively rare to find a person who doesn’t naturally conceive of themselves as one gender or the other. The rules come later. Is that nature or nurture? Obviously I don’t know.
But, for those of us who do deign to consider the possibility of dumping the concept of gender altogether, where does that get us?
Perhaps it just gets us to a place where people are what they are, and if they like pink and baking cakes and want to rule the world and be in charge in their personal interactions, it is all good.




Paula
This seems to be the subject on many minds at the moment I too have been trying to come to a better understanding of how I can be both a man and a woman, or is one just a pretence, started writing about this yesterday, I think I have further to go, your thoughts are helping.
Shannon Townes
I don’t t think you…I …we can completely run away from the construct of gender. The issue, in the humble opinion of Dr. Shannon here, is whether “gender” is defined physically or mentally and emotionally. Are we what our physical body says….or are we what our heart, soul, and mind says? …and if those two don’t match (all in favor say “aye”), then why don’t they? What makes the heart and mind come to such a different conclusion?
And lastly (I’m almost done) if we must change one to match the other, which do we change ….or can we change neither and hope the two will peacefully coexist? Personally, I struggle with that last idea.
Janie
Y’know Shannon, you get me back to a different point of (my) confusion: a while ago I asked what it means to feel like a woman, and no one could give me an answer. I thought that was a bit strange in light of all those who say they know they are female living in a male body. How do they know this if they can’t explain what it means to feel female?
Fionnuala
The purpose of splitting people up into male and female is to propagate the species. Every species has a means to identify potential mates. That’s the (only) reason which is dictated to us by Nature.
Other reasons you’ll here such as women needing women-only space, men needing space to get away from women, are all subjective, meaning the human race is not dependent on men having a place to congregate away from women.
I do think that one way or another, human beings will find a way to reproduce, so the biological reason might not be as… valid, I guess, as it might have been thousands of years ago.
Janie
Thanks for the comment, Fionnuala. I get that there have to be males and females (or rather people with male parts and people with female parts) to reproduce, but I’m not sure that means we have to divide ourselves up along M/F lines. Won’t individual attraction take care of the problem regardless of whether we group people by sex, or even if we mess around with presentation?
I Will Be One Gender or the Other But Not Both at the Same TimeJanieBlack.com
[…] recently asked what purpose is served by splitting everyone up along gender lines. Today, I will offer a different […]